Monday, February 27, 2012
Rhymetime!
Sharpening Pencils
"A dream of cake is a dream, not a cake, but a dream of a journey is itself a kind of journey"
-Marek Halter
I just got back from a 4-week vacation through Hong Kong, Singapore, Kuala Lumpur, and Thailand. I don't wish to write much about what I consider to be the 'boring' details of vacation: What did I do? What did I see? What was my favorite part? Roses and thorns…? Etc. To summarize, highlights included rock climbing on ocean bluffs off the shore of Thailand, eating loads of Indian food, Chinese New Year festivities, and taking a Thai cooking class. What I mostly did during my vacation however, was just feel downright uncomfortable. For me at least, the best way to describe something uncomfortable is to use an analogy. So here we go…
I think people are like pencils. We have something in our core that allows us to leave our mark on the world around us. Sometimes we leave a beautiful mark, and sometimes we make mistakes. We have the ability to fix our own mistakes, but only for so long. If we make too many mistakes, we end up just smearing our problems around and making them all worse. Also like pencils, we regularly need to be re-sharpened in order to leave the best impression possible and avoid mistakes. When I went on vacation this winter, I left my pencil sharpener in Kaili. (Not literally [Well literally, yes, I did.] But for the purposes of this post, I left both my physical pencil sharpener and my metaphysical pencil sharpener in Kaili. OK…?) So, when I'm close to my (metaphysical) pencil sharpener, there is nothing to fear. I am always at my best, I feel comfortable, and if I need a quick refreshing, my familiar sharpener's right there. On vacation, as I felt myself getting duller and duller, leaving a nasty, flat smear in my wake, I found no way to sharpen myself. I just kept grinding down my lead in frustration and using improper sharpening techniques (like chewing the wood away with my teeth) just to get through each day. In the moment, it seemed to be working out pretty well, but now that I'm back in China and can see how rough a trace I really left. I realize that it didn't work well at all, and I need some serious re-sharpening.
To clarify a few things, I don't speak Malay or Thai, nor do I know my way around any part of Southeast Asia that's not China. For vacation, I pretty much threw myself to the wolves and just hoped for their mercy. In this case, the majority of the wolves were conniving racists who saw anything white as a wallet with legs. Unable to use my silver tongue or golden pipes* to prove myself to be otherwise, I constantly found myself in a role I wholeheartedly detest… tourist. *(See previous post entitled "Just to be Frank)
Getting back to China was like cleaning out your ears and suddenly realizing how much the sound had actually been muddled before. I finally had the confidence to approach people, express myself, and ask for/receive help. I guess my vacation gave me some perspective in exchange for 4 weeks of my mental well-being, and for that I'm somewhat grateful. I still think I got ripped off, but, hey, I'm used to it after traveling through Thailand.
Friday, February 24, 2012
Finals... FINALLY!
Fittingly, and with the painful sting of irony, I'll start this post with a properly cited quote.
"But there is one thing that Free-thought can never be by any possibility – Free-thought can never be progressive. It can never be progressive because it will accept nothing from the past; it begins every time again from the beginning; and it goes every time in a different direction. All the rational philosophers have gone along different roads, so it is impossible to say which has gone the farthest."
-G. K. Chesterton… The Ball and the Cross
One of my students plagiarized his final. Well actually, 5 of my students did. Fortunately, my 250 freshmen students all had 1-on-1 interviews, so excepting the possibility that an identical twin showed up to take his/her twin's exam, all my freshmen honestly passed their finals. I gave my sophomores more freedom in the completion of their final exams, and as we all know, with great freedom comes great abuse of the rules.
*Before continuing, it's necessary to give some cultural background here. China is a country of teamwork and community. In America, the community is often subsumed by the individual, whereas in China, the individual is commonly subsumed by the community. No task, however small is ever really undertaken alone. This is why, in the school system, plagiarism and cheating are not understood in the same way as in the west. Where Turnbull takes "free-thought" to the extreme in The Ball and the Cross and uses nothing from others, Chinese students regularly choose the other extreme, effectively eradicating any possibility of doing that which has not already been done.
With this in mind, I designed my final so that the assignment could not be successfully completed while plagiarizing. For their final, each student was supposed to choose one core belief that they held and isolate one experience from their own past which either inspired that belief or evidenced it. I was surprised to find some of my worst students turning in well-written accounts of what they learned during the opium wars, their personal struggle with Asperger syndrome, and their opinion of the asceticism exemplified by modern Chinese architecture. Needless to say (not really), it was pretty to easy to distinguish whether or not a final was plagiarized.
I only gave one of these students a second chance. In fact, the student who took Chinese asceticism too close to heart and didn't indulge himself in the process of doing his own work had not fully plagiarized his paper. He had only misled another teacher into proofreading his paper which he failed to mention was a final for another class. Shockingly, and I mean shockingly, he turned in a FULLY plagiarized paper one week later! After quickly pulling up his life's story on the internet and complimenting him on being a published author, I wrote a zero on his paper and showed him to the door while I gathered my thoughts. I gave my student a second chance, and he still didn't do his own work. In fact he did even LESS of his own work the second time. As other students filed in to present their finals, I transferred the zero to my grade book, and together, the five lonely 0's stood out from all the other grades like bull's eyes denoting those students who I thought would never understand what self-reliance really meant. (Even if they did understand 'ascetic')
Six hours later, after all my other students had finished presenting their final essays to each other, my spirit was lifted by the stories of students whose mistakes were grammatical and not fundamental. Just before leaving for the day, in walks the ascetic himself, out of breath and clutching what seemed to be a third draft of his final. Preparing to hear a well-rehearsed plea for a third chance, I preemptively told this student that I would not change his grade. Shockingly, and I mean shockingly, he did not protest, but instead said only that he understood my decision. He only wanted me to read his final final and give him my corrections.
Though he didn't use the word 'self-reliance' in his final final, I actually believe that he came to understand what it really meant. The belief that he identified for his final was that one should rely on oneself, and the experience he isolated to justify this belief was the experience with this final exam. He used what simple English he possessed to describe why using the work of others impedes one's own development. I hope that the other four students can learn in the next two years what their classmate did on his journey from ascetic to aesthete in just one day.
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
I Prefer Milk and Cookies
Christmas provides us all a time to relax after a long year of work or study. The cold weather pressures us inside, close to our loved ones, where we pass the evening before the soothing crackle of a fire. As expected, that's not the case in China. One of our early cultural sessions began with the advice that whatever we think naturally as Americans, the opposite is true in China. I naturally thought that this was hyperbole… and with just this first thought, I proved my teacher's advice to be true. Everything is indeed totally counterintuitive here, from drinking hot drinks in summer to the basics of righty-loosey and lefty-tighty. You can imagine then, how a relaxing holiday such as Christmas quickly becomes a time for egging strangers in the streets, sillystringing passing cars, and giving out apples which have been completely engulfed in plastic wrapping. It was explained to me that the apples come from similarity of the Chinese name for Christmas Eve (Ping an jie) and the Chinese word for "apple" (Ping guo), but as for the eggs and sillystring… feel free to hypothesize. My best guess is that MaoZeDong watched The Nightmare Before Christmas one year, and took the story a little too literally. When a young gun sprayed one of my friends with silly string, Adam, a fellow volunteer, and I ended up joining in the festivities of Hallowistmas, and covered his face with what had to be toxic shaving cream. Nothing screams Christmas like retaliation and escalation.
The party that we had that night was also a mish-mash of both Jewish and Christian traditions. Our Cranukkah celebration began with the lighting of the menorah, and concluded with a white elephant gift exchange. After the dust had settled over Zunyi and several games of risk had been played till completion, I left with a box of Hungry Jack pancake mix and a bag of Hershey's Chocolate Chips. Despite China's attempts to the contrary, I still got my Christmas cookies.
Thanksgiving
好久不見 - Long time no see. There’s no need (irony) to write about how busy I’ve been since my last post. Strangely enough, that’s what NOT writing indicates. Anyway, now that I have ample free time, I can catch up on all the things I’ve neglected, such as giving thanks.
I am part of Peace Corps China’s 17th batch of volunteers, and that means that I fall into a long line of traditions passed down through the years. In my province, there is a designated place to celebrate every major western holiday except for Thanksgiving. As the story goes, thanks was originally given in Kaili. This was back when there was a fewer number of volunteers, and everyone could stay in just two apartments. Now, there are 40 volunteers in Guizhou, and it is too difficult to host everybody in a small town like Kaili. This year, however, there are four apartments to split in Kaili, and I decided to try to return to old traditions and, with the help of my citymates, we successfully hosted a wonderful Kaili Thanksgiving. Thanks to a generous friend of mine here in Kaili, we had access to a large dining room at a local hotel and set up a big buffet style dinner with what can only be describes as a “unique” Thanksgiving spread. We had pepper chicken and dumplings instead of turkey and stuffing, but there was still pumpkin soup, mashed potatoes with gravy, sweet potato casserole, and even some homemade apple pie. Lastly, to honor the original Thanksgiving traditions practiced by the pilgrims, we concluded the evening with a rousing game of musical chairs.